A recent spectacular crypto heist has brought the whole area into the forefront of discussion once again. And again, so much glamour and mystery attaches itself to the subject that confusion and delusion become inevitable. At base, is the fallacious conflation of crypto with distributed ledger (blockchain) accounting and settlement. Blockchain has many helpful applications that have nothing to do with crypto. Many media discussions have also erroneously linked crypto to proposals for central bank-issued and administered digital currencies. Some unpacking of these associations can at least hint at where today’s muddle will eventually sort out.
Distributed Ledger Is Crypto’s Real Innovation
The most innovative aspect of Bitcoin (and similar cryptos that have followed it) is less the product itself, but the novel accounting and settlement arrangements it introduced to the world. Distributed ledger compares well in many ways to today’s centralized, so-called two-tier accounting and settlement systems. In today’s multistep process, transactions pass through a number of parties, each keeping its own books and records. Today’s approach is comparatively labor intensive, risks errors, and requires that parties carry the expense of holding collateral until every aspect of a trade settles. In contrast, trade and settlement in distributed ledger occur in a single step and can operate seamlessly around the clock. And because distributed ledger time stamps everything, it also makes audits easier and less costly.
Absent these innovations, which clearly have uses quite separate from cryptos, Bitcoin and its fellows—such as Dogecoin and Ether—hardly offer something innovative. They have billed themselves as alternatives to dollars, euros, and other traditional currencies and as a hedge against what inflation does to a currency’s real value. Despite such claims, crypto currencies fail utterly as substitute money. They offer neither a widely used means of exchange, something required of an effective currency, nor the stable store of value that is also required.
True, Bitcoin and other cryptos have occasionally been used to settle transactions. People have bought cars with Bitcoin, for instance, (almost always an expensive luxury vehicle that affords both buyer and seller an opportunity to call attention to themselves as cutting edge). Ransomware hackers also tend to want their transactions in Bitcoin or Dogecoin not because they are a popular medium of exchange, but because crypto confers pseudonymity and hence a measure of anonymity (of which more later). But an occasional contract written in Bitcoin, licit or illicit, does not make it money. Contracting parties could agree to payment in any way they want, in zinc for that matter, but that does not make zinc money.
Meanwhile, the question of a stable store of value is almost risible. True, inflation over time will erode the real value of the dollar or the euro or some other currency in terms of other goods or services. But compared with these crypto currencies, traditional currencies look like a rock of stability. Bitcoin, for instance, rose some 358% from early 2023 to fall 2025, from $25,000 a coin to $114,400. Its value then fell about 47% to mid-2026 and then rose 35% to its recent level of a bit under $80,000 a coin. Of course, these calculations were made in dollars, and some might say that it is not Bitcoin but the dollar that has seen its value vary so radically. But in fact, it is Bitcoin’s value that has swung radically in terms of everything else in the global economy—the cost of a new vehicle, an airline ticket, a household appliance, an hour of a worker’s time, and the dollar.
Crypto Regulation and the SEC vs. CFTC Debate
If Bitcoin and its fellows are not money, the natural question then is: what are they? Washington has debated the question. The Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC’s) desire for supervision led it to claim that cryptos were securities, that is cousin to stocks and bonds. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC’s) desire for supervision led it to claim that cryptos were commodities. The CFTC seems to have won the argument so far, but in reality, cryptos are neither a commodity nor a security.
Unlike Bitcoin and its crypto fellows, both securities and commodities have some economic function going on behind them. Securities have either a stream of payments on a bond or a share of profits afforded a stock. Commodities are a claim on real agricultural goods or minerals, and futures on financial indices are just one additional step removed from the underlying economic activity. Crypto has nothing of the real economy behind it. By design, the supply of each issue is limited and so its price reflects a demand that is largely a bet on the direction of the price going forward. One might say that buyers and sellers of both securities and commodities are motivated no differently, but a link to economic activity still exists.
In light of this distinction, one might best liken Bitcoin and its fellows more to trading in art, antiques, or collectables. With a work of art, a Georgian desk, a genuine Babe Ruth uniform, or the first costume worn by Darth Vader, one has something that is unique or nearly unique and with little or no chance of increasing supply. The price accordingly swings widely with changes in demand. Those changes might reflect a genuine interest in the item in question. More likely they reflect the buyer’s judgment on future demand and hence price swings.
There is another aspect of crypto that deserves mention. Because blockchain accounting and settlement allows a degree of anonymity, these “currencies” gain a special appeal among those dealing in illicit activities. It offers the same hard-to-trace quality of suitcases full of hundred-dollar bills except that it makes the transaction infinitely faster, more secure, and much less cumbersome. This attraction in all probability has held up demand for crypto over time, though no firm data on this point exists. The suggestion here is that should regulation make anonymity difficult, crypto issues could suffer a price correction.
How Stablecoins Differ From Bitcoin
The other sort of crypto—stablecoins—have a different character. These issues are ostensibly tied to a more stable base. Three types are popular. One is a tie to the dollar and U.S. Treasury debt. The market value of such stablecoins can vary from the value of the holdings behind it, but there is a tie that limits extreme price swings. There are also stablecoins that are backed by crypto currencies. These tend to advertise a kind of stability by overcollateralizing the backing, but they ultimately constitute a bet on the inherently volatile pricing of other cryptos. And there are stablecoins that tie to algorithms with no backing beyond a promise that the algorithm will behave as indicated. Although all claim a stable backing, only one variety has it.
Crypto and Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs)
The rise of crypto is often associated with the push for central banks to issue what is usually called “digital currency.” The link is tenuous at best. Whatever the degree of influence crypto has brought to the matter, the term digital currency is entirely misleading. Except for the paper and coins in fewer and fewer pockets these days, all major currencies are already digital. Wire transfers happen digitally in a single computer or when one computer talks to another. A shopper from Detroit can offer his or her credit card to a street vendor in Dubai and digitally convert currency and settle the retail purchase on the spot.
Rather than the existence of crypto, it is more likely that the power of distributed ledger has had an influence on this issue. (There is also an interest in making money a direct liability of central banks and not, as today, a liability of commercial banks. This push to change the nature of money creation, though interesting, takes this discussion on too distracting a tangent to launch into here.) So far, the Federal Reserve has moved slowly if at all toward such a change, and there is clearly political resistance. The matter, however, is not likely to go away, especially as more and more commercial arrangements adopt distributed ledger. But if crypto has had little impact on the possible advent of digital currencies, their advent nonetheless promises to have a big effect on crypto and generally.
One important concern is that the central bank administration of money transactions and settlement would, whatever efficiencies it offers, also give the authorities tremendous surveillance opportunities. Every transaction would effectively occur on a government computer. The Fed would know where you take your dry cleaning and how often, what concerts you bought tickets for, what books and magazines you bought, where you traveled, and so forth. Because such arrangements could easily give the authorities an ability to erase the anonymous quality of Bitcoin and its fellows, the digital currency could also remove one huge appeal that cryptos presently have. These qualities are no doubt why the People’s Republic of China has pioneered digital currency and has also banned crypto, though from what little detail is available, China does not seem to be using blockchain. No doubt privacy issues will loom large in any Fed move to adopt a digital dollar.
The Future of Blockchain in Accounting and Settlement
However, the Fed and other central banks decide on digital currencies or deal with crypto, one certainty is the appeal of distributed ledger in accounting and settlements. Entirely separate from its introduction in Bitcoin, blockchain’s security, efficiency, and cost effectiveness are compelling. Its broad application will require adjustments and safeguards, but it will nonetheless bring a revolutionary change whether crypto lives or dies.